By Monica Migliorino Miller
“Beam me up Scotty.” These are an abortionist’s words directing a nurse to turn on the suction machine, words Abby Johnson heard when she was unexpectedly summoned to the procedure room of the Bryan, Texas Planned Parenthood clinic, of which she was the manager, to assist in an ultra-sound guided abortion. She was stunned to observe that the 13 week-old fetus pulled away from the invading suction cannula. Johnson recounts the abortion in her 2010 book Unplanned: “The cannula was already being rotated by the doctor, and now I could see the tiny body violently twisting with it. For the briefest moment it looked as if the baby were being wrung like a dishcloth, twirled and squeezed. And then the little body crumpled and began disappearing into the cannula before my eyes. The last thing I saw was the tiny, perfectly formed backbone sucked into the tube, and then everything was gone.” Unplanned, the film, opens with this riveting depiction of abortion violence. Based on Johnson’s book the movie chronicles the former Planned Parenthood clinic director’s odyssey into the abortion practice and how her complicity in the killing of this unborn child drove her out of what Johnson herself calls the “death house” and into the arms of the pro-life movement.
As Johnson instantly was mentored by founders of 40 Days for Life and quickly catapulted into the role of a pro-life spokesman, perhaps it was only a matter of time before Christian film-makers would mount her story onto the big screen. Directed by Gary Soloman and Chuck Konzelman, the latter known for God’s Not Dead, it is produced by the same Christian-oriented film company PureFlix. Ashley Bratcher turns in a very compelling and believable performance as Johnson in a role demanding a wide-range of emotion—not the least of which is Johnson’s immediate reaction to the abortion she just witnessed as she isolates herself in a bathroom overcome with heart-wrenching grief she must keep hidden from her fellow abortion clinic workers.
Unplanned starts with the college-age Johnson who, during a volunteer fair on the campus of Texas A & M, stops by a Planned Parenthood display table and is recruited as a clinic volunteer escort. She is lured into the abortion practice believing that Planned Parenthood isn’t simply about abortion, but offers women a wide range of services to which they might not otherwise have access or be able to afford. The clinic director Cheryl, hard-nosed and intimidating, contrasted with the well-meaning, naïve, and ultimately confused Johnson, soon promotes the new-comer to a real job as clinic counselor. And when Cheryl is herself rising up the Planned Parenthood corporate ladder and moving to PP headquarters in Houston she encourages Johnson to apply for her position.
Oddly, Johnson, who considers herself a Christian, believes that if God didn’t want her to have the promotion she wouldn’t get it. As it turns out, she did get the job and celebrated that God had blessed her career move! Eventually Johnson would become seriously disillusioned with the actual goals of Planned Parenthood. The awakening began when she attended a corporate meeting of clinic directors in Houston, officiated over by her former career-driven boss Cheryl. It was becoming clear that the money-making “service” provided by Planned Parenthood was abortion. Johnson learned that Planned Parenthood sought to increase the number of abortions, including late-term abortions to which she had always been opposed.
At the meeting she objects to the new corporate plan prioritizing abortion, only to be harshly admonished by Cheryl for not getting with the program. She states to a nearly cowering Johnson: “We are an abortion provider!” Finally, when Johnson sees the actual killing of an unborn child in that ultra-sound guided abortion, she convicts herself of having facilitated the deaths of 22,000 unborn children and makes a decision to leave Planned Parenthood forever. That very day Johnson appears on the doorstep of the nearby offices of the Coalition for Life where she is warmly welcomed by its director Shawn Carney and other staff who, ironically, faithfully protest outside the very fence of the Planned Parenthood she just escaped. Now Johnson joins them, the very people she once opposed and pleads for the lives of the unborn.
The benefit of Johnson’s conversion to the pro-life cause is the fact that she knows from personal experience the sadness, corruption, and lies of the abortion industry and in particular Planned Parenthood. The fact that upon her resignation Johnson didn’t just go home to live a quiet life, but instantly aligned herself with the pro-life cause made her a serious threat to the abortion giant.
Unplanned is a valuable movie if for no other reason it does something no other pro-life-related feature film has done, including Gosnell. Unplanned doesn’t hide or sanitize the violence of abortion as did, to its artistic detriment, and to avoid the dreaded “R” rating, the Gosnell movie. This is not to say that no other pro-life movie has ever exposed the violence of abortion. In the 1980s and early 1990s several very effective hard-hitting pro-life educational videos featured abortion and abortion victims, such as Assignment: Life, Eclipse of Reason, Hard Truth and of course The Silent Scream. That now the reality of abortion itself is revealed in a feature-length movie with the goal of wide distribution makes UnPlanned unprecedented.
Some in the pro-life movement are very dismayed that the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) slapped Unplanned with the “R” rating convinced the agency was motivated by bias against its message, that the rating was politically designed to keep audiences from patronizing the film, daunting even a Christian audience that typically avoids such movies, with Gibson’s The Passion of the Christ, a notable exception. Those who denounce the “R” rating fail to see that such a rating actually gives credibility to a film about abortion. After all, films are an innately visual medium. How do you make a movie about a place that kills people without showing what actually goes on inside an abortion center? Thus, from its opening scene Unplanned is a movie with dead bodies and lots of blood.
The movie’s visual content is at least borderline between a “PG-13” and “R” rating. And yes, since the movie is about the controversial subject of abortion the scales were undoubtedly tipped toward audience restriction. This is not to say that the film is dominated by bloody, disturbing images. It is not. But to the credit of its producers Unplanned does not succumb to cinematic contrivances to avoid the gravity of its subject matter in order to garner a milder rating. Should anyone make a film of my book Abandoned—The Untold Story of the Abortion Wars and craft it to escape an “R” rating they failed to be faithful to the gravity of the book’s content.
Unplanned does some things exceptionally well. Oddly, the disturbing opening scene of the suction abortion isn’t necessarily the most shocking, nor the most poignant. The film focuses on how Johnson aborted her own two children. While engaged to a man she would marry and then divorce, she discovers that she is pregnant and while she is ambivalent about whether to abort the baby, her fiancé is not. He tells her “We’ll take care of it”—which leads her to the first abortion. Then when divorced, Johnson finds she is pregnant again with her ex-husband’s baby. Wishing to sever all ties with this immature, frivolous man she obtains an RU-486 abortion at the very Planned Parenthood where she volunteers as an escort. Having been told that such an abortion would simply entail a “gentle emptying of the uterus” her chemical abortion is anything but. As the cramping starts Johnson writhes in pain, vomits, runs to the bathroom where film viewers have a front row seat to Johnson’s chemical abortion ordeal that ends in a bathroom splattered with blood. At the scene’s end the room is filmed from above with Johnson viewed from afar, lying on a floor in her blood, pathetically curled in fetal position—eerily matching the very fetal position of the unborn baby she helped to abort. A well thought-out cinematic statement takes place here: she and her victim have become one.
Unplanned is a well-done, professionally-rendered faith-based movie, with a strong script and strong performances. It deserves to be seen and promoted. However, it did succumb to some of the usual pitfalls of this film-genre and its directors made some choices that limit the film’s cinematic artistic impact. Unplanned, consistent with Johnson’s book, wants to make a statement about positive versus negative pro-life activism. And there’s nothing wrong with that. But the point is made through shallow, artificial contrivance. The day Johnson arrives to volunteer as a clinic escort, a crowd of pro-life demonstrators is assembled outside the fence separating them from the clinic property. The crude, angry, judgmental, pro-lifers are juxtaposed with those who are peaceful, caring, and compassionate. The pro-lifer representing the wrong kind of activism, calling women “murderers,” is fat, old, and ugly. The “good” pro-lifers—are all young, good-looking, and slender. In order to make a quick point, both come off as little more than caricatures. The approved pro-lifers are well-mannered, well-spoken with nary a hair out of place. They always do the right thing, say the right thing, are never weary, frustrated or, God-forbid, angry. Oddly Johnson’s abortion clinic colleagues are portrayed with more realism, are more believable as flesh and blood persons than the way Coalition for Life members are depicted in the film.
The drama is driven forward by narration supplied by Johnson’s character, again a kind of unnecessary artifice which caused the movie to at first almost take on the quality of a video tutorial on abortion, rather than a feature film on the subject. Thankfully this sense of the narration subsided and the cinematic force of the film took over.
This movie reviewer is a pro-life leader who has vested interest in the success of any movie that deals with the injustice of abortion. A good film such as this that deals with injustice should be seen by as wide an audience as possible. However, Unplanned, like nearly all faith-based movies, is directed to the audience that will most likely support it and go see it—namely those already against abortion. Certainly the “R” rating should signal that this movie is a serious treatment of the subject of abortion; nonetheless, Unplanned did not completely avoid the overt preachiness of films made by Christians, most evident in the movie’s closing climactic scenes dominated by inspirational soft-rock Christian vocals driving home the point of repentance, God’s love, and God’s forgiveness.
All of this is very edifying to the initiated, but potentially off-putting to those who otherwise may be willing to take a leap and expose themselves to a movie that presents abortion negatively. Christian film-makers just try to do too much. They can’t just make a movie against abortion, but have to overtly express the Christian foundation upon which the anti-abortion position rests. And it may very well be that the producers and directors believe that they must approach their subject this way because the audience-base to which the movie is primarily directed, namely a pro-life Christian audience, expects such a film to do so and will leave theaters disappointed, perhaps even complain that the movie wasn’t Christian.
In a film such as this, those Christian aspects need to be organically, and, dare I say, subtly woven into the fabric of the film’s story and not artificially laid-over the story with excessive, needless statements, and, frankly, sappy Christian music which presents Christian themes in a contrived and trite faith-based package. We know Abby Johnson is repentant and that this film is about redemption. Filmmakers just need simply to show us—not tell us.
While Unplanned may be accused of these drawbacks, it is, when all is said and done, a bold piece of filmmaking. It will strengthen the resolve of those already committed to ending abortion and bring those uncertain about their position to embrace the pro-life cause should they go see it. On the other hand, we can expect hard-core “pro-choice” activists to hate this movie, ignore it, or try to dismiss it since Unplanned dared to shine a light on the sordid violence of abortion.
This story originally appeared on https://www.crisismagazine.com/